Amy Spillman — Compass Indiana profile banner

Amy's Ratings & Reviews

(33 total)
Newest First
Write Review
Jacquee Gordon
Seller
2549 Plano Dr, Whitestown, IN 46075

Amy went above and beyond for our family! Not only is she extremely knowledgeable in the real estate industry, she is kind, caring, and a very supportive to my husband and I through all of the steps of selling and buying a home. After our first meeting, I instantly trusted her, and it was a wonderful experience. We were so fortunate to have Amy as our agent!

Verified by
Mary Myers
Seller
7256 Camberwood Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46268

Amy was incredible throughout the sale of my home on Camberwood. When the first offer came in and didn’t feel right, she fully supported my decision to decline it. Just a few days later, a cash offer came along, and Amy negotiated it beautifully. She even managed to shorten the closing date by two weeks. Her professionalism, communication, and steady guidance made the entire process smooth for me. I’m grateful to have her as both my realtor and my friend, and I highly recommend her.

Verified by
SHARON MOSELEY
Buyer
2698 Old Rosebud Ln, Westfield, IN 46074

I was very pleased to work with Amy, as my daughter and her husband recommended her, and I couldn't be happier! Amy went above and beyond in every way! I highly recommend Amy for all your real estate needs.

Verified by
Jeremy Chiddister
Seller
6114 Hardwick Dr, Whitestown, IN 46075

Amy is the gold standard of how a realtor should be. If you're considering a real estate transaction, she is the first call you should make!

Verified by
Liz and Abhi
Buyer
12231 Valley View Cir, Indianapolis, IN 46229

We are so grateful to Amy for her incredible dedication and hard work in helping us find our dream home. After a long search, she never gave up, always persevering and keeping our needs at the forefront every step of the way. Amy was patient, responsive, and truly had our best interests in mind. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor and highly recommend her to anyone looking for a home.

Verified by
Janet and Bill Warner
Seller
6975 Milhouse Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46221

Amy is the consummate professional. She took the time to get to know us and to understand why we were selling our home and what that sale represented for our future. Amy was responsive through calls, texts, email and in person communication as needed. We felt that Amy understood the market here and how our home sale fit in that context. We would highly recommend Amy to anyone looking to sell or buy a home. Her integrity and professionalism were unimpeachable.

Verified by
Samantha T
Buyer
18886 Shefler Blvd, Noblesville, IN 46062

Amy was recommended to us when we started our next home search. After seeing some preexisting homes and a few models we decided to go with a new build! Amy was extremely helpful when going through each and every detail and step of the new build process!

Verified by
Mary Myers
Buyer
19566 Atwater Ave, Sheridan, IN 46069

Amy was supportive throughout my home‑buying process. She truly heard my critiques of different places and used them to find me the perfect home. Her negotiation skills made me feel confident that I got the best deal. I’m grateful for her guidance and highly recommend her.

Verified by
Yvette R.
Buyer
6287 E Roselyn Dr, Mooresville, IN 46158

Amy always demonstrates professionalism, market knowledge, and dedication. Communication was always prompt and clear, and she patiently answered all my questions along the way. Whether it was scheduling viewings, negotiating offers, or handling paperwork, she was always on top of things and made sure every detail was handled efficiently. What truly sets Amy apart is her genuine care for her clients. In particular, Amy went to bat for me when I faced an issue with the inspector missing major home problems. She advocated on my behalf, making sure those concerns were addressed and that my interests were protected even after the sale was finalized. Additionally, Amy provided the necessary encouragement and motivation to ensure I completed all required paperwork for the purchase in a timely manner. Her diligence and follow-through kept the process moving efficiently, and her attention to detail ensured that nothing was overlooked. In short, Amy is amazing and great to work with!

Verified by
Halle & Rick Hill
Buyer
10819 Upland Way, Noblesville, IN 46060

I have worked with Amy in the past and she has always been amazing to work with! We plan to keeping working with her for future homes as she knows a lot about the Indianapolis area and was able to guide us to exactly what we were looking for in a home and community. She also communicated efficiently/effectively and made so much time for us. We could ask her anything and she would be transparent with feedback, offer solutions/alternatives, and answer questions in a way we could understand. She is a joy to work with!

Verified by
1 2 3 4
11 - 20 of 33
Amy Spillman, Compass Indiana — real estate agent
Compass Indiana