Andy Fenstermacher — RE/MAX Pinnacle profile banner

Andy's Ratings & Reviews

4.8

(24 total)
Newest First
Write Review
Vivek Shah, Lancaster PA
Seller
612 Warminster Lane Lititz
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

My experience with Andy has been excellent! From the start to close. Everything was done quickly from contract to photos to listing. Andy was always available to answer my calls and provide answers when I needed them. His knowledge of the local area helped me get top dollar!

Verified by
Michael Flynn, Lancaster
Buyer
136 N Mary Street Lancaster
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Andy and his mother Darlene were referred to me by Marcia Rubini, my Aunt, from Remax in Toledo, Ohio. She is a consummate professional Realtor and said that she would research to find me the absolute best Remax agent in Lancaster, PA. She absolutely did. Was extremely happy with her referral and my interactions with both Darlene but especially Andy. I have been very critical of real estate agents that I've had represent me in the past. Andy far exceeded my expectations and did an outstanding job in every possible aspect of the sale. He receives my highest recommendation and referral. Andy receives my highest recommendation for the wonderful job he did handling my transaction. I even had a family emergency when we first toured the property that demurred my decision for a week. He was very sensitive to that situation and I greatly appreciated it.

Verified by
Estate of Nancy Winn
Seller
2827 Mimosa Lane, Lancaster
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Verified by
Helen Sauer
Buyer
208 Cool Creek Way
4.6
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Andy was very patient, thorough, and accommodating with our requests.

Verified by
Ben Miller, Narvon PA
Buyer
643 Meadow Hill Drive
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

I can certainly say that we made the right choice in using Andy as our realtor for the second time in a matter of four years. He does a great job in understand our needs and wants, and he also helped us negotiate a great deal on our purchase. His reliability was key because with all of the stress that is involved in moving, Andy handled all of the required documentation in a timely manner so that all my wife and I had to worry about was packing and physically moving. This was very important for us as we agreed to settle on both our old home and our new home in under 40 days. Andy is courteous and polite, but also tough enough to get you what you deserve. He is also flexible in meeting on short notice. Based on everything above, in addition to being a great guy to be around, I would highly recommend Andy Fenstermacher as a realtor as you begin to look for your next home.

Verified by
Patrick Lever & Lindsay Wiley
Buyer
117 Knights Lane
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Verified by
Patrick Yeager
Seller
18 Barnstock Court
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Verified by
Earl and Lindsay DeLong
Buyer
43 Old Post Lane, Lititz
4.8
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Verified by
Cathy Cammauf
Seller
50 E. Main Street, Ephrata
4.9
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Verified by
Turnier and Courtney Esperance
Seller
625 Frome Avenue, Lititz
4.9
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Verified by
1 2 3
11 - 20 of 24
Andy Fenstermacher, RE/MAX Pinnacle — real estate agent
4.8
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
RE/MAX Pinnacle