Bethany Nartker — Coldwell Banker Realty Central Northwest profile banner

Bethany's Ratings & Reviews

5.0

(54 total)
Newest First
Write Review
Rebekah, Grove City
Seller
5264 Berthold Pass Dr.
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Bethany was amazing to work with. She is very detailed oriented, responds quickly, and was on top of every step of the process. She took away any stress I had throughout the entire process. I would definitely recommend her to anyone else looking to buy/sell as well as work with her in the future.

Verified by
Jennifer Comstock
Buyer
1639 Rock Creek Dr.
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Bethany was very on top of everything and always quick to respond to any questions I had. She is also very personable and approachable, while still being professional.

Verified by
Brian Fasilis Grove City
Buyer
5880 Ravine Creek Dr.
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

My aunt couldn’t have said enough about my broker. To have a broker be Friendliness / personable (which mine was) Bethany was AWSOME!!! Bethany goes above and beyond the call of duty. Bethany is so personable and easy to talk to. Bethany goes 110% to make sure her client is happy and a totally Awsome outcome. I personally liked the energy and effort Bethany puts forward (it can’t be matched). I felt like I could ask Bethany anything and Bethany knew what to do every time. Any time I needed something Bethany was able get it done and if she couldn’t find an alternate method to get it done. VERY IMPRESSIVE!!! I think that Coldwell Banker King Thompson Arlington Regional Office should be very lucky and proud that they have a shining star (Bethany Nartker) in their branch. I would recommend and use your office and Bethany to anyone that needs to sell or buy. I definitely would not change to anyone else. AWSOME!!! My aunt couldn’t have said enough about my broker. To have a broker be Friendliness / personable (which mine was) Bethany was AWSOME!!! Bethany goes above and beyond the call of duty. Bethany is so personable and easy to talk to. Bethany goes 110% to make sure her client is happy and a totally Awsome outcome. I personally liked the energy and effort Bethany puts forward (it can’t be matched). I felt like I could ask Bethany anything and Bethany knew what to do every time. Any time I needed something Bethany was able get it done and if she couldn’t find an alternate method to get it done. VERY IMPRESSIVE!!! I think that Coldwell Banker King Thompson Arlington Regional Office is awsome. You should be very lucky and proud that they have a shining star (Bethany Nartker) in their branch. I would recommend and use your office and Bethany to anyone that needs to sell or buy. I definitely would not change to anyone else. AWSOME!!!

Verified by
Merri LeBlanc, Fredericktown
Buyer
76 W. Sandusky Street
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Bethany should be the spokesperson for Coldwell Banker. She surpasses each category in excellence! Bethany was there for us every step of the way. Anytime I had a question or any doubts(which were many!), she was just a phone call or text away to provide answers or reassurance. Bethany stayed on top of and pursued the finance company when things came down to the wire just before closing. Although the process was stressful, Bethany handled everything and kept us informed throughout. She has earned our trust completely!! It was originally out of my hands when Bethany was “assigned” to help us. However I feel that she really listened to us and our requests. She didn’t complain once about us dragging her all over central Ohio! She was there every step of the way for us. She was vital in finding us our forever home. We’ve known Bethany less than 2 months time yet we feel like she’s family.

Verified by
Marti Marcum
Buyer
3256 Belstead Dr.
4.9
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Bethany is an excellent agent. All of the above applies to her. I have been looking to purchase with other agent's for three years with no success. They did not listen to my wishes, however, Bethany did. It did not take her very long to find what I needed in a home.

Verified by
Jan & Chuck Shafer
Buyer
2154 Ravine Woods Dr.
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

We met Bethany last Memorial weekend (2019), was in Columbus attending my grandson’s HS Graduation. My son took a chance and called Coldwell Banker/Upper King Thompson Arlington Office to see if we could meet with an agent as my husband and I were relocating in the Columbus Ohio area (lived in Cape Coral, Florida 22 yrs). Bethany Nartker, took the time to meet us at the office and was so welcoming, informative, and genuine in trying to find us a new home near our sons. My husband and I knew Bethany was the agent for us. Bethany kept in contact with us from that day until the end of our journey when buying our Condo at the Ravines, in Grove City, Ohio. I must tell you she has become like family to my husband and I along with our two sons. Bethany would email us links weekly, daily on suitable homes/condos and we would often talk on the phone updating our needs and wants. Her wisdom, knowledge and compassion was above and beyond of what we expected. Bethany is a breath of fresh air, full of enthusiasm and making us comfortable. Prior to the virus, Bethany would come and pick up my husband and I up to look and the for sale homes in the Columbus, Grove City, Hilliard and surrounding areas. We moved in with our son in Columbus, January 1st and Bethany was in touch with us the week to set up dates to view properties. Bethany spent so much time with us, researching area that would work for us. THAT SHE DID!! God Bless Bethany Nartker, WE LOVE HER! Very professional at all times, even when we would go to an open house, you could tell how she respected other agents looking at the property as well, speak kindly and always knowledgeable. Bethany would get up into the attic space, look at all the appliances, furnace, water heater etc and make sure they were in good condition. There were a few instances that she would even make a call to check on furnace, AC etc. OUTSTANDING! We never had any agent take such great care of us. Such a relief! Bethany took extra time with my husband and I when it came time to the contracts to make sure we understood the process. Bethany even made us a to do list, and also a list with all the scheduled events, dates and closing. Such a help for us as we are in our 70’s. Thank YOU, Bethany! You will always be in our thoughts and prayers. One of a KIND!

Verified by
Jeanna Brown. Galloway
Buyer
5828 Sundrops Ave.
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Our experience with Bethany was absolutely a very good one. She was with us every step of the way-- and was always quick to respond to anything we needed. We highly recommend her to family/ friends. She is an excellent communicator-- and she leaves no stone unturned. You can tell that she doesn't consider being a realtor a job-- but something she truly loves . She found such joy in finding us exactly what we were looking for in a house. I believe she was "almost" as happy as we were ! After living in the same house for 41 years-- my husband and I are looking forward to this new chapter in our lives -- in our new ranch home. Thanks Bethany Nartker We appreciate you so very much.

Verified by
Anthony Markwas
Buyer
6070 Springburn Drive
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Verified by
TJ Markwas, Muirfield Village
Seller
3328 Parksley Ct.
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Bethany has become a true friend and trusted advisor during the process of buying and selling our homes. She did an amazing job of meeting both my wife's expectations and my own in finding a new home. As somewhat picky buyers, we had high expectations to find the home that we wanted at a reasonable price, and within somewhat specific areas of Columbus. Given the state of the market, we found many we liked, but realized we were stretching the budget to get there. Bethany assured us that we would find the right house in the right price range, and she came through with that promise pretty quickly. We were able to sell our former home and buy our new home without any major issues, and I give Bethany Nartker full credit in making it happen so smoothly.I would not want to work with anyone else in the house selling/buying process!

Verified by
Halle & TJ Markwas
Buyer
6070 Springburn Dr.
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star

Bethany's passion for her clients was clear to us from the beginning. As busy, working parents of a toddler we needed someone with efficiency, care and patience. Bethany fit all of these qualifiers and more. One particular piece I'd like to highlight is "timely" and "clear" communications. We have quickly learned that Bethany's efficiency is not common place. She was always 5 steps ahead which we greatly appreciated.

Verified by
1 ... 4 5 6
41 - 50 of 54
Bethany Nartker, Coldwell Banker Realty Central Northwest — real estate agent
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Coldwell Banker Realty Central Northwest