Jay listened to what we were looking for and pointed us in the right direction. His knowand understanding of the process was spot on. We are using his services to sell as well.

Jay was amazing. Our closing had lots of unforseen setbacks and he was there every step of the way to help us through it. Great at communicating. Great at finding answers when we had questions. Very knowledgeable. Would highly recommend.

Jay was an absolute pleasure to work with. He made selling my late mothers house so easy and helped with everything along the way! I would recommend him to anyone!

I am very lucky because Jay Mattlin was recommended by a friend. His experience, knowledge, and personality made my journey easier and fun. He was always available and kept me up to the minute informed. He's not only my real estate agent, I made a new friend. I really appreciated his knowledge when we met a few obstacles, which he handled like the pro he is.

Love Jay's style! We had to move a million different parts simultaneously and very quickly. He conquered every one with ease. If he was sweating, he hid it well which also gave me reason to remain calm as well. Jay's smart, knows the market, ready to move on a moments notice-- in a nutshell: I'd do it again without question! Thank you Jay. You're the best!

I had never sold a home before and had very little knowledge about the process in selling a home. Jay's knowledge, extensive experience and dedication quickly put my mind at ease. He supported me throughout the process with a personal touch. The communication he provided was prompt and always consistent. I was going through a difficult time with the passing of my mother and the needing to get her home ready to list. Jay was very understanding and compassionate and supportive throughout the process. His integrity and ethics went beyond my expectations and his help during the closing was greatly appreciated. I want to thank Jay once again for everything and congratulations on being elected Vice President of the Lancaster Realtor Board for 2026.

Jay Mattlin was incredible to work with! He handled the sale of my homes with professionalism, confidence, and clear market expertise. His communication was consistent and transparent every step of the way, which made the entire process stress-free. Jay’s knowledge of the market helped us price the properties perfectly and get great results quickly. I felt completely supported and knew I was in good hands. Highly recommend Jay and the Key to Home Property Group!

I have used Jay to sell real estate for several years. Jay handles the entire process, from start to finish, with expertise and dedication. Every transaction is smooth and Jay keeps you updated and informed along the way. I wouldn’t work with anyone else.

Jay made the process easy for me to sell my home, nothing but straightforward communication and honest answers to any questions I had along the way. Way easier than I anticipated. Jay was even able to get my part of the closing moved up so our vacation wasn’t interrupted. And kept me up to date along the way as things progressed.

Working with Dustin was a fantastic experience! He was always very straightforward with us, while being respectful of our situation and goals in buying a new home. He also shared valuable insight about the current market conditions and the challenges therein. We couldn't have asked for a better advocate for helping us sell a home that we loved, but had outgrown. We would absolutely seek out Dustin to work with again in the future!