Jay Mattlin — Key Realty profile banner

Jay's Ratings & Reviews

5.0

(65 total)
Newest First
Write Review
Matt and Donita Westman
Buyer
8515 Priestley Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Working with Dustin & Jay was a fantastic experience! Their expertise and commitment to finding the right home steadied us every step of the way. We will use them again & recommend them highly!

Source: Other
Natalie and Andrew Curtis
Seller
361 E Walnut St, Lancaster, OH 43130

During every step of our home sale journey, I felt that Jay always put our best interests first. He communicated everything to me in a very professional way. Jay worked very hard to make the transition from our old house to our new house the best possible experience.

Source: Other
Natalie and Andrew Curtis
Buyer
2545 Stringtown Rd, Lancaster, OH 43130

Jay and Dustin were the absolute best. They gave us answers to any and all questions we had throughout the buying and selling process. If they didn’t know the answer, they found the resources to get them. Their dedication to ensure we found the perfect house was shown in every showing, every offer, and every rejection we received. Thru every battle, they were there, reassuring us that they would find our home. Dustin and Jay were kind, offered incredibly comforting words, and were very professional. They had excellent communication with us thru the entire process and made sure we understood what was going out the entire sale and purchase. I never plan to move again, but if I do, I will not hesitate to call them. I will make sure anyone I know and love uses these fellas to find their home! If you want agents who have your best interest in mind from start to finish, look no further. Dustin and Jay made an incredibly hard process go smoothly. 12/10 recommend for all your real estate needs!

Source: Other
Raeanne Spangler
Buyer
343 Ridgemere Way, Lancaster, OH 43130

Jay has so much knowledge of the Fairfield county area and is familiar with the market and what you need as a buyer, which makes using him as your realtor so wonderful. He’s always a step ahead, so you’re never left wondering what happens next. Thank you for everything, Jay. We couldn’t have done it without you.

Source: Other
Kait and Fred Murray
Seller
760 Montmorency Dr, Pickerington, OH 43147

As usual, Jay worked his magic on the sale of our home. This is the third transaction Jay has worked on with us. He handled the open house and additional showings while we were on vacation and we sold for much higher than I expected. He shielded us from some time wasting mistakes made by the buyers agent and hand delivered our closing proceeds after the title company noted the buyers forgot to sign some documents.

Source: Other
Angela Seimer Marvin
Seller
140 Berwick Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130

Jay is the only realtor I will use. He is knowledgeable, helpful, and efficient. Jay makes the selling process as easy as possible and is always there for his clients.

Source: Other
Maddie Holbrook
Buyer
140 Berwick Dr, Lancaster, OH 43130

Jay and Dustin were both very helpful throughout this process. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience!!! Amazing experience and I would recommend to anyone!

Source: Other
Jennifer Wheeler
Seller
206 Water St, Lancaster, OH 43130

Jay and Dustin were the absolute best. They gave us answers to any and all questions we had throughout the buying and selling process. If they didn’t know the answer, they found the resources to get them. Their dedication to ensure we found the perfect house was shown in every showing, every offer, and every rejection we received. Thru every battle, they were there, reassuring us that they would find our home. Dustin and Jay were kind, offered incredibly comforting words, and were very professional. They had excellent communication with us thru the entire process and made sure we understood what was going out the entire sale and purchase. I never plan to move again, but if I do, I will not hesitate to call them. I will make sure anyone I know and love uses these fellas to find their home! If you want agents who have your best interest in mind from start to finish, look no further. Dustin and Jay made an incredibly hard process go smoothly. 12/10 recommend for all your real estate needs!

Source: Other
Kait and Fred Murray
Buyer
6300 Heigle Rd SW, Amanda, OH 43102

This was our second time using Jay to buy a house and he always gets it done. We were looking for a specific type of home for a long time. Closing became a challenge with the sellers but Jay worked it all out and we closed on time.

Source: Other
Tracy Samworth
Seller
7609 Burkey Dr, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Selling a home and moving a distance away from family is always hard. Jay helped by making the process of selling the home seamless. The timely reminders throughout the process were very helpful- keeping us all on track.

Source: Other
1 2 3 ... 7
11 - 20 of 65
Jay Mattlin, Key Realty — real estate agent
5.0
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Key Realty