Sheila Straub — Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley profile banner

Sheila's Ratings & Reviews

4.9

(91 total)
Newest First
Write Review
Katie Van Schoyck
Seller
148 S. Kellner Road

Sheila is a true gem in real estate. She knows the Bexley/Eastmoor area well and brings that expertise to her clients, whether buyers or sellers. She is compassionate and truly cares about the comfort and confidence of her clients, making sure they understand each step of the process. Sheila was integral in both my first home purchase and home sales, and I felt confident that with her guidance I was in capable hands with these important decisions. Without a doubt, Sheila gives the same high level of service and care to her clients buying and selling in all price ranges, and that is truly something to cherish in a realtor. 10/10, I would highly recommend having Sheila buy your side for any real estate needs.

Verified by
Brenda Dutton
Seller
67 North Chesterfield

Sheila Straub was a pleasure to work with on selling my house. She is a great communicator & totally organized.

Verified by
Lucy Gerlach
Buyer
226 S. Dawson Avenue

If you are in the Columbus market, specifically the Bexley area, Sheila Straub is the only realtor to work with. Her knowledge and expertise of the area, the nuances of the housing market and the home buying process are amazing. She reduced the stress assocaiated with the home buying and selling process. She communicated extremely well. Sheila truly had our best interest at heart. Make Sheila apart of your team, and you will come out a winner all around!

Verified by
Cindy Beckett
Seller
110 S. Ardmore Road

Sheila was the best partner in this very big transition for me. She is the best!

Verified by
Megan Allman, Gahanna
Seller
2735 Allegheny Avenue

Sheila Straub is truly one of a kind. She is a true professional and clearly very knowledgeable about her trade. She was spot on in all of her advice and made us feel heard, supported, and valued every step of the way. Sheila will always be our first call for any real estate need and we will glowingly endorse her to all of our friends and family.

Verified by
Curtis and Megan Allman, Gahanna
Buyer
755 McDonell Place

Sheila Straub has certainly been a blessing; this is our second purchase with her. She will also be helping us sell a home as well. Sheila is like family now. Sheila's knowledge and expertise were invaluable. We also walked through many homes on the road to this one that fits us very well. Extremely pleased with her in all respects. We will be recommending her to everyone we know in the area.

Verified by
Ysais, Northern Columbus.
Seller
781 Montrose Avenue

I really don't think there is anyone better than Sheila in the real estate business in Columbus. I don't cease to be impressed with her skills, calm demeanor, and efficiency with real estate transactions. She helped my wife and I buy the home of our dreams and sell our older home in a matter of weeks. Her knowledge of real estate transactions is combined with experience and a sixth sense to get the deal done. One of my obsessions is efficiency and being a high performer, Sheila embodies efficiency and high performance. I recognize game when I see game. Both of our transactions with her were smooth, hassle free, and the team around her is phenomenal. If you want to have a flawless experience with the best realtor in the city, I strongly recommend you reach out to Sheila.

Verified by
Hedwig Noll , 128 N. Cassingham Rd, Bexley
Seller
2798 Brownlee Avenue

Sheila Straub as a person is very likable and professionally just the best.

Verified by
Jim Bushong, NYC to Bexley
Buyer
781 Montrose Avenue

We had a wonderful homebuying experience working with Sheila Straub. She was originally recommended to us by a friend, and looking back on the process we can't imagine having gone through it with anyone else. Sheila was exactly what we wanted in a realtor: extremely knowledgeable of the local market, professional, ethical, and an absolute pleasure to work with. Moving from NYC to Bexley could have made the challenge of finding a home in a very low-inventory market even more difficult, but she kept us informed and up to date every step of the way. She was extremely timely when we reached out with any questions, and always offered support and guidance. She also provided multiple options for all of the associated professionals required during the process (mortgage broker/home inspector/etc), and each and every one of them proved to be of the highest quality. My wife and I are so grateful to Sheila for her hard work on our behalf, and it goes without saying that she has a new client for life!

Verified by
Betty Horton, Westerville, OH
Seller
3340 Mason Road NW

Sheila absolutely knows the market. House sold in less than 24 hours. My head is still spinning and Sheila was cool as cucumber. Quite a ride. So glad I let her drive!!!

Verified by
1 2 3 ... 10
11 - 20 of 91
Sheila Straub, Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley — real estate agent
4.9
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley