Sheila Straub — Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley profile banner

Sheila's Ratings & Reviews

4.9

(91 total)
Newest First
Write Review
Jeff Burger
Buyer
767 S. Roosevelt Avenue

I was not expecting to be able to buy a house in a market like this with such low inventory and such high prices until Fall 2022. Sheila and her team helped me navigate these waters and I'm writing this review from my new home in Spring 2022.

Verified by
Heather, Bexley, OH
Buyer
2670 Sherwood Road

Sheila made a somewhat challenging buying process extremely smooth. She truly took my needs into consideration every step of the way to make sure that I was not only satisfied, but that every detail was handled professionally. Sheila was able to schedule the inspection with a preferred company on a Sunday to accomodate my schedule. Sheila is caring, thoughtful, knowledgeable, and excellent at communication. I would recommend Sheila Straub for all of your real estate needs.

Verified by
Bill Sundermeyer
Seller
53 N Stanwood Rd., Bexley, OH

If I had another house for sale in Bexley I would definitely utilize Sheila.

Verified by
Meghan, Columbus
Buyer
2823 Bryden Road

My family has worked with Sheila on a couple of occasions and gave her very high praise - she definitely lived up to the hype! Sheila was very thorough and incredibly helpful and answered all of my questions promptly. As a first time homebuyer, she was great to work with and very kind and supportive throughout the process. Sheila is top notch and made the stressful and somewhat intimidating home buying process a breeze!

Verified by
Emily Whitney, Bexley Ohio
Buyer
41 N. Ardmore Road

Sheila is the best there is. She is a true professional, exceptional ambassador to the Bexley community and an overall generous spirit. She makes herself available always, responsive to the utmost, and provides so much insight and perspective into the home buying process. Her long time commitment to the Bexley community also allows her to help new residents get plugged in to the community and all the resources they will need in the home buying process. I was in the unique situation that the house I wanted was also her listing. The unbiased integrity she showed to both me (buyer) and the seller made me certain that I truly found the best agent in town. I can not say enough wonderful things about Sheila and her team, professionally and personally.

Verified by
Caren petersen
Seller
41 N. Ardmore Road

Sheila straub was wonderful to work with. She is knowledgeable of the bexley market and what homes would be appropriate for which buyers. She is responsive and on-the-ball. Highly recommend.

Verified by
Blake Rikard, Bexley
Seller
2738 Allegheny Avenue

Only minutes after meeting Sheila, I knew she was going to be a great asset in my home selling journey. That first meeting, she made me relaxed, was honest and upfront about what to expect, and made me feel very relaxed. This was my first sale. Throughout the process, Sheila was in constant contact, gave me great recommendations for repairs and got me in contact with some excellent handymen. Even though the sale took a bit longer than expected, Sheila and her team were in constant communication with me and handled everything appropriately. I would recommend Sheila Straub and her team for any potential home buyer or seller. Thank you for everything!

Verified by
Scott Bone, Central Bexley
Buyer
74 South Stanwood Road

Sheila is fantastic from concept through completion.

Verified by
Chris and Heather Dehn, Bexley
Seller
167 South Roosevelt Avenue

Sheila did another phenomenal job in quickly listing and selling our home. She is the most responsive professional we have ever worked with, and her knowledge and expertise is truly the best to navigate this fast moving real estate market. Thanks Sheila for all of your help!

Verified by
Sky & Colin, Southern Orchards
Buyer
572 Hanford Street

Sheila Straub was recommended by a co-worker as someone who was knowledgeable and experienced in the area, which is what we as new home buyers really needed. She was wonderful! A fount of knowledge who helped us with a myriad of concerns. As lifelong renters, we didn't know what to look for when buying but Sheila gave great advice and was able to deal with a complicated seller on our behalf. We got a solid deal on our house and are very happy with it. If we want to sell one day, Sheila will be the first person we call.

Verified by
1 ... 4 ... 10
31 - 40 of 91
Sheila Straub, Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley — real estate agent
4.9
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley