Sheila Straub — Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley profile banner

Sheila's Ratings & Reviews

4.9

(91 total)
Newest First
Write Review
Sarah Mangia, Bexley
Buyer
81 South Chesterfield Rd

Sheila really is the best around. She knows Bexley inside and out, is patient, hardworking, kind, and a great negotiator. There’s truly none better!

Verified by
Bob Masys Columbus Ohio
Seller
2501 Fair Avenue

All aspects of the sale were handled professionally and efficiently by Shelia. She brought in a photographer to produce a beautiful printed booklet showing my house in the best possible light. Showings were handled easily. There was steady feedback via e mail. Questions and concerns were address quickly and the final sale was after thoughtful discussion of the market and status of our showings. Shelia does an excellent job.

Verified by
Richard Larrimer
Buyer
401 Zimpfer Street

We couldn't have accomplished our goal without Sheila's knowledge and guidance. My family and I will always be indebted to her in getting into our new home. She was always there for support and answered every question very timely. Sheila Straub was 2 steps ahead of every issue or concern. Truly amazing! In this current seller's market you don't think you need a realtor to sell a house, which may be true in some cases. But, you sure as heck need a realtor to buy a house!! I would highly recommend Sheila Straub to anyone for BOTH selling your house and purchasing your new home. Especially if you are lookin gin the Bexley, German Village, Merion Village areas.

Verified by
Erica Gregory, Bexley, OH
Buyer
196 South Cassingham Road

When I asked some friends, who are residents of Bexley, about Sheila, they all said she was great. After my initial conversation with her, I could tell that she truly cares about selling Bexley properties, because she's a long-time resident and loves her community. I was a first-time buyer and Sheila was very patient with me, when I asked questions. She was also very good about guiding us through this process in such a competitive market. Overall, Sheila was a dream to work with! Her ethics, industry knowledge, and attention to detail make her stand-out against other Realtors in this marketplace. I can't imagine having gone through the process with anyone else!

Verified by
Joshua Kilmer, Hilliard, OH
Buyer
5765 Redsand Drive

Given that my wife and I were first time home buyers, we had no frame of reference to go off of in our work with Sheila. However, now that we have experienced Sheila there is no way that we could not imagine having gone through this process without anybody as gifted and skilled as Sheila. Her attention to detail was phenomenal. She was on top of everything that came our way, and never hesitated to ensure that we felt comfortable at every step. I highly recommend Sheila for any home buyer!

Verified by
Caroline Moore, Bexley
Buyer
2265 Astor Avenue

We knew we wanted to move to the Bexley neighborhood and heard Sheila Straub was the broker to use as she is very knowledgable and well connected in the Bexley neighborhood. I can't imagine the process going any smoother. Sheila was great and very attentive. We know how busy she is, but we always felt like we were a top priority. Sheila was always very positive and gave us her professional opinion on properties.

Verified by
Randall Merritt, Columbus, Ohio
Buyer
6222 Marias Point Lane

I have two words for anyone selling their home - Sheila Straub! We have never sold a house before, and we were pretty stressed about it. Sheila calmed us down and made the process relatively pain free. She was not only our realtor, she was our therapist, as well! We interviewed three candidates for the job. Although they all seemed quite capable, Sheila was in a class by herself. She made the choice easy!

Verified by
Samantha, Columbus
Buyer
481North Parkview Avenue

Our experience with Sheila was fantastic from start to close...and even after! Sheila was proactive, truly leading us through the process. She communicated often and ensured our understanding for each next step. Her deep knowledge of the Columbus market is evident, and she is skilled in negotiation. I am grateful for the harmony Sheila created around both our sale and purchase transactions, she is truly the best and we could not be more pleased with every aspect of the service Sheila provides.

Verified by
Dan, Columbus
Seller
175 Broadleigh

Sheila Straub is the go-to source for home sales in central Ohio--especially in Bexley/Eastmoor. Her depth of knowledge is beyond impressive, and her work ethic cannot be beat. Sheila's team of professionals brought their 'A game' to the sale of our home through the photography, video, print, and well positioned digital communications. Her guidance on pricing was so helpful and spot-on. Her knowledge of, and references to, other vendors was also appreciated and yielded a similar high-level of customer satisfaction. While I'm certain she was balancing other client's needs and sales, we always felt that Sheila deployed the entirety of her time and attention into our purchase/sale representation, and to us as clients. That's a component of the home buying experience that can't be beat, and is hard to replicate.

Verified by
Randy and Lori Merritt
Seller
708 Chelsea Avenue

We interviewed three brokers. Sheila Straub was above and beyond the most knowledgable of the three. Sheila Straub made the entire process as easy as one could imagine. She sold our house in one day! Sheila could not have worked any harder in getting our house sold quickly at a great price. She was with us every step of the way and was available seven days a week. Kayla Kuno assisted Sheila through the selling of our house. She did an excellent job as well. Sheila Straub made the experience of selling our house so very easy and stress free. We have already suggested to a few of our friends who are thinking of selling their home they would be crazy to have anyone but Sheila represent them.

Verified by
1 ... 7 ... 10
61 - 70 of 91
Sheila Straub, Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley — real estate agent
4.9
Star Star Star Star Star
Star Star Star Star Star
Coldwell Banker Realty Bexley